May 1, 2011. Cafeteria Restaurant and Bar. New York City.
I’m drinking a white grape martini and eating mac and cheese spring rolls, which are delicious by the way, when I get the urge that I get all too often: the urge to check Twitter to ensure that I’m up on the latest and greatest news both worldwide and with my friends (@monsieurnelson if you’re unaware). As I look down my timeline, I realize that something has happened. Something bigger than usual. I know this because 90% of the people I follow, from fashion designers to photographers to college buddies to sports reporters, are all talking about the same thing:
President Obama announces that Osama Bin Laden, the Lord Voldemort of the non-Hogwarts world, has been killed by U.S. Military forces.
So the big questions that I received from many of my friends on both sides of the intellectual scale is “What is your response?” & “What is your response to others’ responses?”
Let’s tackle these and other expansion questions separately.
WHAT WAS MY RESPONSE?
Like many other African Americans, my initial and secondary responses to this were not much different from my responses upon finding out that Sen. Barack Obama was the new president elect back in 2008. What might strike many as odd was that my responses were very minimal to both.
Do I care about Politics? Do I care about the War on Terror? The answer to both is a “very limited yes.” I care about these issues only on the basis in which they directly affect my life, mainly because they do not care about me beyond these things.
I remember the extreme jubilation following the announcement of the election results. I was still in undergraduate study at Prairie View A&M (Historically Black University). Just imagine what it was like when 9,000 black people between the ages of 18 and 25 heard that Obama had been elected. There were people crying, people laughing with gladness and even people heckling others. There was an unhealthy mixture of both happiness and vindication, of joy and vengeance. You see, there is about a 2% white population at Prairie View and the some of the black population, like any population anywhere, are extraordinarily discriminatory and saw this as an opportunity to “stick it to the white man.” Either way, regardless of your race, political affiliations, gender, age or educational level, that was a significant event and I understood exactly why the reactions were so dramatic. It was a historic day. A day that marked the end of an era and the beginning of the next.
My response to that historic day was one that most people around me had trouble understanding. I did not celebrate at all. No text messages sent. No Facebook status. No high 5’s and no “YES WE CAN. YES WE DID.” This sparked many to ask me whether or not I had actually voted for the man whom my girlfriend at the time’s family said I resembled (mainly because they live in Germany and the pool of light skinned, multiracial American they have seen is small). Full disclosure: I DID. So I told you what I didn’t do. The question is now probably, what did I do? I finished writing a paper that I had been toiling over for a class that I hated. I ate something that probably had more calories that the last black guy to run for president had votes. Then I went to sleep. The reality, mine anyhow, was one of extreme realism. I came up with a simple way of explaining it to people: “My life won’t be any different tomorrow than it was yesterday because of this news.”
You see, politics, whether good or bad, haven’t largely affected my life. I was born poor under Reagan. I was raised in poverty (and poorly) under both George Sr. and “the Ladies Man.” And while everyone was complaining about the terrible job George Walker was doing in the early years of the new millennium, I decided that like his predecessors, Republican or Democrat, I couldn’t depend on him to improve my life. I could only depend on my personal network and myself. So I did just that and work to be better and frankly less poor everyday thereafter. It worked. And after seeing it work, I lost interest in politics before I ever had a chance to be interested in the first place.
But since I had decided years earlier and had seen presidents from both parties come and go, I was sure that my life would probably not change on a day to day after President Obama’s election and inauguration. But after a few months, when the inauguration came, I thought, “You know what, this is pretty cool. It’s the end of an era of struggle for a lot of people who have worked really hard for an idea. This event is the personification of that idea. This is what they consider to be their goal being reached. Good for them. And in many ways, I’m a part, however small, of that group/struggle. So good for me.”
My response the other night to the news of Bin Laden’s death was almost identical.
While the range of responses was as wide as I’ve seen for any event in recent history, from glee to sorrow, from cautious celebration to cynicism, I was extremely unresponsive. I saw what was happening, knew that it was important and historic, but somehow remained unmoved. I proceeded with lethargy through my night in NYC. Then I got word that “OMG OMG PEOPLE ARE MEETING AT GROUND ZERO TO CELEBRATE!!!” via text. I was still not excited despite being less than two miles from the exact spot. As Twitter burst into uproars in 1000 different directions I felt the need to express myself in 140 characters or less. “I was getting bread when Osama Bin Laden was alive, I will continue now that he’s gone.” What a prick, yes I know.
WHAT WAS MY RESPONSE TO OTHERS’ RESPONSES?
But just as the inconsiderate, self-interested jerk in me subsided with the election, the same transpired with this event. Over the next few days I saw the passion in people. Those who held the “Never celebrate someone’s death no matter what” as well as the “Yes I’m glad he’s dead and I hope he burns in hell (Samuel L. Jackson voice).” And as much as I wanted to side with one or the other and get in on the colour commentary action, I just didn’t fall into either of those categories. I respected them both on some level but felt that both were being a bit insensitive.
The group who say that you shouldn’t get any joy or positive feelings from the death of another: think about the justice system. When a child molestation or murder suspect is convicted of a crime and sentence to either life imprisonment or death penalty, is the family of the victim wrong for feeling the relief or joy of knowing that justice is being served? Is it wrong to get a positive feeling from the closure you receive that only said justice can provide? Well, there is a large possibility that that was exactly what was provided to the loved ones of the 2,752 who died at the World Trade Center and the 184 whose lives were lost at the Pentagon on that Tuesday morning. The single headline “WE GOT THE BASTARD!” may very well have provided that closure. And who are you…better yet, who are WE to say whether or not the way that anyone responded was right or wrong? My conclusion was not that it was right or wrong, rather, that it was fine.
WHAT NOW?
I’ve heard other rumblings that suggest that this wasn’t as significant a feat as the media and government have made it out to be. That Al Qaeda will simply utilize the chain of succession and the next in power will continue to orchestrate the reign of terror the way that OBL did the past 20 or so years. Well, luckily for all of us, that group doesn’t know shit about the way that evil empires work (Nazi Germany, WWII Japan, Al Qaeda, etc.). They are generally based on a series of small acts that are encouraged and climax in one large act (The Holocaust, Pearl Harbor, 9/11). That act then serves as a vital source to add to the movement those who were unsure of the impact that said group could make. Immediately following the large act though, the evil group must survive a surge of opposition.
This is where things got sticky. In the other two cases I’ve cited, the enemy was clear. They were nations. Germany. Japan. We go there. We kill them. We kill the leader. We win. Well, it wasn’t that cut and dry this time. 9/11 couldn’t be narrowed down to one nation; rather it was accredited to a smaller group of underground radicals from many nations who live in utter secrecy. That makes it impossible for our nation to “go there” and it makes them a lot harder to kill. What we did have was their leader’s name. That was the good news. Great news, actually because just like in the other evil empires, the acts are fueled by the ideas of the leaders of those empires. The strength of the movements lived not only in the acts of the past and plans for the future but the idea that “we are strong because our leader is strong.” This was especially the case in Nazi Germany. A vast number of enlisted Nazi’s were relieved upon finding out that Hitler was dead. Relieved because they knew like I know now. That many evil acts are in obedience to not only the ideas of evil but also the deliverer of that evil. Once Hitler was dead, no matter who took his place, the shoes would never be filled. There would be a certain resistance. A “Hitler wouldn’t do it like that” mentality.
Those mentalities work just fine in democracies but no so much in “kill them all” organizations. So I am forced to ask, who takes Osama Bin Laden’s place? You don’t know, you say? Well neither does the 16 year-old kid who is training to be a suicide bomber. He has lost a piece, no matter the size, of his motivation; he has lost his figurehead. He is a member of the Foot Klan with no Master Shredder (see TMNT). And when your job is to lose your life for the cause, you need all the motivation in the world. Don’t think that I’m saying that terrorism is over. It’s not. I am saying that that movement is weaker on this day than it has been in the last 10 years. And I’m saying, in a very celebratory tone, that that is an extremely good thing for us here in the Colonies.
HATE. That is what Osama Bin Laden embodied. He was the personification of modern day terrorism. He was almost everything that is wrong with the grander world. He ruined and ended many lives that held so much promise. He ruined mass travel. He made children and adults afraid to go to school and work respectively. He made life a lot harder for folks whose lives were hard enough already. I can’t imagine what it must have been like to lose your loved one to a heinous act of cowardice orchestrated by a man who has never met you or your family but want all of you dead at any cost, even the lives of his own loved ones. My heart and prayers go out to those families and friends.
BUT THANKS TO OUR BRAVE MILITARY, ESPECIALLY THE CORPORATE REBELS OF SEAL TEAM SIX, THAT ENTIRE LAST PARAGRAPH AND ANYTHING ELSE EVER WRITTEN ABOUT osama bin laden WAS, IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE IN PAST TENSE.
God Bless America. Land of the Free. Home of the Brave.
M